Discussion: View Thread

  • 1.  Nicolai Foss & Libby Weber in AMR Origins Series, Episode 14.

    Posted 08-19-2021 23:40

    Nicolai Foss & Libby Weber in AMR Origins Series, Episode 14...

     

    In this episode, Libby Weber & Nicolai Foss discuss their forthcoming Academy of Management Review article, coauthored with Siegwart Lindenberg, titled "The Role of Cognition and Motivation in Understanding Internal Governance and Hierarchical Failure: A Discriminating Alignment Analysis."

     

    YouTube video: 

    https://youtu.be/WaiXHvKb94Q

     

    Podcast audio: 

    https://anchor.fm/amr-origins-series/episodes/AMR-Origins-Series---Episode-14---Libby-Weber--Nicolai-Foss---Siegwart-Lindenberg-e1661rd

     

    --------------------------

    Professor Richard Makadok

    Brock Family Chair in Strategic Management

    Krannert School of Management

    Purdue University

    http://www.makadok.com

     

    "It is better to fail in originality than to succeed in imitation."

    -- Herman Melville

     

     



  • 2.  RE: Nicolai Foss & Libby Weber in AMR Origins Series, Episode 14.

    Posted 08-20-2021 10:38
    Dear Richard,

    I appreciate the amount of work that goes into creating these AMR Origin Series conversations but I'm also disappointed to see that a scholar who has called women's writing about their experiences in academia "trivial, whiny, jargon-ridden, and crammed with hyperbole" featured so prominently here. Since when is insulting female colleagues and their work acceptable in academia? 

    best,
    Banu

    ------------------------------
    Banu Ozkazanc-Pan, Ph.D.
    Professor of Practice, School of Engineering
    Academic Director, IE Brown Executive MBA
    Director, Venture Capital Inclusion Lab
    Brown University
    Co Editor-in-Chief, Gender, Work & Organization
    Forthcoming (2021): Entrepreneurial Ecosystems: A Gender Perspective, Cambridge University Press
    Forthcoming (2022): A Transnational Approach to Entrepreneurial Ecosystems, Cambridge University Press
    ------------------------------



  • 3.  RE: Nicolai Foss & Libby Weber in AMR Origins Series, Episode 14.

    Posted 08-21-2021 11:58

    Richard,

    I have to agree with Banu. AOM's policy states, "We provide an inclusive, dynamic, and supportive community for all of our members,
    embracing the full diversity of our backgrounds and experiences."  It is really hard for members to believe that this is taken seriously, when it not only publishes, but elevates, the work of people who openly express sexism and racism.

    https://bulletin.nu/social-justice-studies-in-the-university-why-did-they-emerge-despite-being-anti-scientific

    Best,

    Caren



    ------------------------------
    Caren Goldberg
    Associate Professor
    Caren Goldberg, Ph.D., LLC
    VA
    ------------------------------